10 tips to lead the way

What makes a great sustainability report?

Bees
  • Blog
  • 8 minute read
  • 22/01/25
Dr. Philipp Thaler

Dr. Philipp Thaler

Senior Manager, Sustainability & Climate Change, PwC Switzerland

Petra Schwick

Petra Schwick

Partner, Assurance, PwC Switzerland

Christophe Bourgoin

Christophe Bourgoin

Partner, Finance Transformation Platform Leader and Sustainability Platform Leader, PwC Switzerland

Dr. Astrid Offenhammer

Dr. Astrid Offenhammer

Director, Sustainability & Strategic Regulatory, PwC Switzerland

Excellence in sustainability reporting is no longer optional: it's a competitive necessity. Find out how any company – irrespective of size or sector – can achieve outstanding reporting by focusing on key criteria and drawing on the expert methodology developed by PwC and ILE-HSG.

Navigating the evolving sustainability landscape

The world is in flux, and this dynamic environment is also reflected in the field of sustainability reporting. While the reporting landscape is becoming increasingly formalised, best practices of clear and consistent application of the new standards are still emerging. The Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) will require many companies to publish sustainability reports applying the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS) starting from financial year 2024 or 2025.

For such organisations, particularly those preparing their first sustainability report, this change raises critical questions:

  • Are our sustainability disclosures aligned with the required standards?
  • Are we reporting the right amount of data, or are we at risk of disclosing too much or too little?
  • How does our reporting compare with our industry peers?
  • Beyond disclosing the right information, what else should we consider?

Answering some of these questions goes beyond mere compliance. Thoughtful, well-structured sustainability reporting can refine corporate strategy, demonstrate accountability, and build trust. Companies that view sustainability reporting as a strategic tool, rather than a regulatory obligation, can gain a competitive advantage.

What is great sustainability reporting?

To help companies navigate the changing landscape of sustainability reporting, PwC Switzerland and the Institute of Law and Economics at the University of St. Gallen (ILE-HSG) launched the Swiss Sustainability Reporting Excellence Awards in October 2024. The awards recognise companies that demonstrate outstanding quality, transparency, and comprehensiveness in their sustainability reporting (not judging the sustainability of their business practices). The assessment methodology, which reflects the latest research, evaluates a wide range of industries and highlights different levels of reporting maturity—showing that some companies are already performing at an excellent level and others have room for improvement. 

This methodology can be used not only to evaluate existing reports, but also to provide valuable insight and inspiration for current and future reporting. It combines objective metrics with expert judgement to provide a balanced and comprehensive assessment of companies’ sustainability disclosures. While the detailed methodology and assessment criteria are available here, this article provides practical tips for enhancing any company’s sustainability reporting.

Differences and links between sustainability and sustainability reporting

Sustainability and sustainability reporting are distinct but interconnected concepts. The ultimate goal is to foster more sustainable business practices. Sustainability reporting serves as a powerful tool to advance this aim. By transparently disclosing their sustainability performance, companies enable stakeholders—such as investors, consumers, and employees—to gain a comprehensive understanding of their practices and make more informed decisions. This transparency, in turn, encourages companies to improve their sustainability efforts. The Swiss Sustainability Reporting Excellence Awards aim to enhance reporting quality, thereby driving meaningful progress toward sustainability.

10 tips for effective and impactful sustainability reporting

Ensure that your sustainability reporting is aligned with recognised standards such as the ESRS or the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) for greater reliability and comparability. Incorporate frameworks such as the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), the Science Based Targets Initiative (SBTi) or the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) to increase credibility and relevance. Regularly review and update your practices to stay in line with evolving guidelines and stakeholder expectations.

Comprehensive reporting builds trust and allows for meaningful benchmarking, making the completeness of your data a critical aspect of sustainability reporting. Avoid omitting information as gaps can undermine trust and the reliability of the report. Use benchmarking against peers to identify areas for improvement and ensure that your disclosures remain competitive, comprehensive, and relevant.

Ensure that your sustainability report addresses the topics that really matter to your business and stakeholders by prioritising material issues identified through a Double Materiality Assessment (ideally based on a robust framework, such as provided by ESRS). Align your disclosures with industry-specific guidelines , such as the GRI or Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) sector standards, to maintain relevance and credibility. These frameworks can provide valuable guidance while you wait for ESRS sector standards to be issued (expected mid-2026). Avoid overemphasising less critical areas.

Comparative data adds credibility and highlights progress over time, making it an essential part of sustainability reporting. Including figures from previous years allows stakeholders to observe trends and assess the company’s performance over time. The use of consistent metrics is equally important to ensure that data is comparable from year to year. This consistency provides a clear and reliable basis for assessing progress and identifying areas for improvement.

Stakeholder engagement enriches your sustainability reporting by including diverse perspectives and ensuring relevance. Clearly stating how you have engaged with different groups demonstrates transparency and accountability. Integrating stakeholder feedback into your strategy and reporting further enhances its value. Showing how their input has been incorporated in your approach underlines your commitment to collaboration and responsiveness.

Use clear, straightforward language to make your report accessible to a wide audience, including investors, customers, employees and the community. Avoid unnecessary jargon, but tailor the language to the needs of your stakeholders and the objectives of the report to ensure it remains meaningful and engaging. Readability tools can help to reduce complexity where necessary.

Transparency in sustainability reporting requires acknowledging both successes and challenges, so it is important to maintain a balanced tone and language. Mentioning both achievements and areas for improvement builds credibility and trust. Avoid excessive self-promotion, and when addressing challenges, provide context on steps being taken to improve.

A well-designed and accessible report increases engagement and usability. Offer multiple formats such as interactive web versions and PDFs, include linked tables of content and provide clear headings for easy navigation. Use graphics to simplify complex data and offer multilingual options – including at least one local language and English – to reach a wider audience.

Third -party assurance builds trust in your sustainability reporting. Commissioning an independent audit/review from a reputable firm, adds credibility and ensures the accuracy of your report. This can also be relevant to companies not subject to CSRD, e.g., smaller companies who are suppliers to CSRD-reporters and want to use their voluntary reporting to increase their ESG-score. Being transparent about the scope and opinion of the external assurance will further strengthen stakeholder confidence.

Although sustainability reports are increasingly standardised through key performance indicators (KPIs), they should still reflect your company’s unique identity and strategic objectives. Aligning your reporting with broader goals ensures relevance and creates a distinctive narrative that resonates with stakeholders.

Excellent reports for every industry and business size

Our assessment methodology provides the conceptual framework and forms the foundation of our comprehensive database of reports from all public interest entities listed on SIX and Swiss-based companies with revenues exceeding CHF 1 billion. This extensive dataset reveals that sector differences exist at an aggregate level, with the utilities sector performing best overall and pharma and healthcare lagging. Yet excellence is not confined to any particular industry – within each sector, leading companies demonstrate outstanding sustainability reporting.

Graph 1: The quality of reporting differs across sectors

Source: Swiss Sustainability Reporting Excellence Awards

Companies in the utilities sector achieve an average fulfilment degree of 64.3% against set criteria, while those in the pharmaceutical and healthcare sector score an average of 53.3%.

Our assessment reveals a correlation between company size and reporting quality, suggesting that the resources available are a key factor influencing reporting quality. While larger companies are more likely to produce higher-quality reports, smaller organisations can also excel by playing to their strengths and focusing on best practices. Even with limited resources, thoughtful and well-executed reports can stand out and serve as an example for others.

Graph 2: The quality of reports rises with realised sales revenue

Source: Swiss Sustainability Reporting Excellence Awards

What can an assessment bring?

PwC’s assessment methodology provides clarity, support and confidence to help companies navigate the complexities of sustainability reporting. Continuously updated to reflect new developments, it helps organisations benchmark their reports against industry peers and broader benchmarks, identify areas for improvement, and align reports with their objectives and stakeholder expectations.

By highlighting evolving best practices and distinguishing between must-haves, should-haves, and nice-to-haves, the PwC assessment enables companies to adapt to market trends and produce meaningful reports. Leveraging our unparalleled database and deep expertise, we go beyond scoring and KPIs to help organisations refine their strategic focus and optimise standardised reporting to meet their unique needs and audiences.

Your sustainability reporting experts

Dr. Philipp Thaler

Senior Manager, Sustainability & Climate Change, Zurich, PwC Switzerland

+41 79 422 62 08

Email

Christophe Bourgoin

Partner, Finance Transformation Platform Leader and Sustainability Platform Leader, Zurich, PwC Switzerland

+41 58 792 25 37

Email

Petra Schwick

Partner, Assurance, PwC Switzerland

Email

Dr. Astrid Offenhammer

Director, Sustainability & Strategic Regulatory, PwC Switzerland

+41 78 696 32 11

Email